From left to right, we have: Zoya Ana, Zoya Chantal, Nails Inc London Radnor Walk, and China Glaze Sunset Sail. I have the polishes in the same order on my nails in the photos below.
These polishes are pretty surprisingly different once you get them on the nail! Ana is a Satin finish - somewhere between glossy and matte - which comes as no surprise since that's right on the bottle. Radnor Walk actually dries to a matte finish, which is a bit of a surprise since it's not written on the bottle at all. And Sunset Sail has a bit of a shimmer to it, but its shimmer is much more subtle than that of Radnor Walk.
Angled more towards the light to purposefully get a glare - to demonstrate the different finishes.
Colorwise, these polishes kind of pair up: Sunset Sail is almost the same shade as Chantal, though SS leans perhaps a touch more peachy; and Ana and Radnor Walk are very similar shades, though the pinkish sparkle in RW does make it look a bit pinker overall.
I found that using flash was the best way to show the differences in finish - and to actually show off the shimmers in Radnor Walk and Sunset Sail. My camera wasn't really picking up the shimmers at all - and the flash on my camera is ridiculously bright at its lowest setting, so I took this picture on my phone.
These colors are altogether much more different on the nail than they are in the bottle! There are definitely no dupes here.
So, Do I Need Them All? Sure! These babies are definitely all different from each other. The sparkles in two of them, the matte and satin finishes, and the two different main color tones make them very different nail polishes. Until I really got in to collecting nail polish, I probably would have picked only one of these four, because I wasn't really in to nude polish. Which one, I'm not sure, but I use to wear nude colors so rarely that I didn't care to own similar shades! However, for someone who loves doing nail art but works a job where nail polish can't be too colorful, I would say that you definitely need all of these! Just be sure to grab a Satin and a matte top coat if you want to secure your manicure and retain the different finishes featured in this post.
Was this post helpful to you? Are there any specific polishes that you'd like to see compared in this series? Let me know in the comments!